Heat pump data · 26 metro areas
Heat pump or gas furnace: which costs less to run where you live?
It depends on two prices, and they differ a lot from place to place. We worked out the cost of heat from an efficient heat pump and from a 95% gas furnace in 26 metro areas, at each one's own energy prices and winter.
The short version
- At today's prices an efficient heat pump costs less to run than a 95% gas furnace in 12 of the 26 metro areas we cover that have piped gas, and gas costs less in the other 14. The heat pump wins everywhere we cover in Texas, Georgia, Florida, Arizona, Washington, North Carolina and Oregon. Gas wins everywhere we cover in New York, California, Illinois, District of Columbia, Pennsylvania, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Colorado, Maryland and Missouri.
- The heat pump's biggest lead is in Miami, where its heat costs 39% less than gas heat. Gas has its biggest lead in Detroit, where it costs 59% less.
- It is close (within 10%) in Charlotte, St. Louis and Portland: there, the rebate, the air conditioner you'd otherwise buy and the gas account's fixed charges decide it.
- Against electric baseboards or an electric furnace, the same heat pump cuts the cost of heat by 55% to 64%.
- Running cost is one part of the decision. The buying guide covers the rest: what it costs to install, the rebates, sizing and the three systems we pick for each climate.
Place by place
Cost of one million Btu of heat delivered to the house. The heat pump figure uses the seasonal COP for that winter (shown under it), which includes backup heat and defrost. Metro areas in one state share its average prices. Each links to its own heat pump page, with the rebates.
| Metro areas | Electricity, ¢ per kWh | Gas, $ per therm | Heat pump, $ per million Btu | Gas furnace, $ per million Btu | Gas price where they tie | Cheaper to run |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| California | ||||||
| Los Angeles, Riverside, San Francisco, San Diego | 33.6¢ | $2.12 | $35.18seasonal COP 2.8 | $22.32 | $3.34 | Gas, by 37% |
| Texas | ||||||
| Dallas–Fort Worth, Greater Houston, San Antonio, Austin | 15.9¢ | $1.87 | $16.62seasonal COP 2.8 | $19.68 | $1.58 | Heat pump, by 16% |
| New York | ||||||
| New York City | 29.9¢ | $1.70 | $31.30seasonal COP 2.8 | $17.89 | $2.97 | Gas, by 43% |
| Florida | ||||||
| Miami, Tampa, Orlando | 15.0¢ | $2.46 | $15.73seasonal COP 2.8 | $25.89 | $1.49 | Heat pump, by 39% |
| Illinois | ||||||
| Chicago | 19.2¢ | $1.09 | $22.53seasonal COP 2.5 | $11.47 | $2.14 | Gas, by 49% |
| Georgia | ||||||
| Atlanta | 16.3¢ | $1.97 | $17.03seasonal COP 2.8 | $20.74 | $1.62 | Heat pump, by 18% |
| District of Columbia | ||||||
| Washington, DC | 25.2¢ | $1.61 | $26.39seasonal COP 2.8 | $16.95 | $2.51 | Gas, by 36% |
| Pennsylvania | ||||||
| Philadelphia | 21.7¢ | $1.45 | $22.73seasonal COP 2.8 | $15.26 | $2.16 | Gas, by 33% |
| Arizona | ||||||
| Phoenix | 15.4¢ | $1.79 | $16.10seasonal COP 2.8 | $18.84 | $1.53 | Heat pump, by 15% |
| Massachusetts | ||||||
| Boston | 30.5¢ | $2.42 | $35.74seasonal COP 2.5 | $25.47 | $3.40 | Gas, by 29% |
| Michigan | ||||||
| Detroit | 23.1¢ | $1.05 | $27.02seasonal COP 2.5 | $11.05 | $2.57 | Gas, by 59% |
| Washington | ||||||
| Seattle | 14.7¢ | $1.70 | $15.40seasonal COP 2.8 | $17.89 | $1.46 | Heat pump, by 14% |
| Minnesota | ||||||
| Minneapolis–St. Paul | 17.4¢ | $1.06 | $23.25seasonal COP 2.2 | $11.16 | $2.21 | Gas, by 52% |
| Colorado | ||||||
| Denver | 17.0¢ | $1.08 | $19.93seasonal COP 2.5 | $11.37 | $1.89 | Gas, by 43% |
| North Carolina | ||||||
| Charlotte | 15.2¢ | $1.58 | $15.87seasonal COP 2.8 | $16.63 | $1.51 | Heat pump, by 5% |
| Maryland | ||||||
| Baltimore | 21.4¢ | $1.56 | $22.41seasonal COP 2.8 | $16.42 | $2.13 | Gas, by 27% |
| Missouri | ||||||
| St. Louis | 16.1¢ | $1.44 | $16.84seasonal COP 2.8 | $15.16 | $1.60 | Gas, by 10% |
| Oregon | ||||||
| Portland | 16.0¢ | $1.61 | $16.72seasonal COP 2.8 | $16.95 | $1.59 | Heat pump, by 1% |
Prices are the EIA's state averages for home customers: electricity for July 2026, natural gas for 2025 (the annual average, which is steadier than a summer month).
The number to watch: the tie price
A furnace turns about 95% of the gas it burns into heat. A heat pump moves heat instead of making it, so over a winter it delivers 2.2 to 2.8 units of heat for each unit of electricity in the places on this page, less where winters are colder. That ratio is the seasonal COP.
So the comparison comes down to two prices. For each place, the table gives the gas price at which the two systems cost the same to run. In New York City that is $2.97 per therm , and gas there costs $1.70, so gas is cheaper to run today. If gas gets dearer or electricity cheaper, the answer moves toward the heat pump, and the other way round.
To check your own bills, use the price of your last unit of each:
- Heat pump, per million Btu of heat: electricity price per kWh × 293 ÷ seasonal COP.
- Gas furnace, per million Btu of heat: gas price per therm × 10 ÷ 0.95.
Against oil, propane and electric baseboards
Where there is no gas line, the comparison is easier. The table shows the largest metro in each state we cover; a blank means we hold no home price for that fuel there.
| Metro area | Heat pump | Electric baseboards | Oil furnace (85%) | Propane furnace (93%) | Saving against baseboards |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Los AngelesCalifornia | $35.18 | $98.50 | — | — | 64% |
| Dallas–Fort WorthTexas | $16.62 | $46.54 | — | $36.46 | 64% |
| New York CityNew York | $31.30 | $87.63 | $52.92 | $43.10 | 64% |
| MiamiFlorida | $15.73 | $44.05 | — | $57.19 | 64% |
| ChicagoIllinois | $22.53 | $56.33 | — | $21.50 | 60% |
| AtlantaGeorgia | $17.03 | $47.68 | — | $36.20 | 64% |
| Washington, DCDistrict of Columbia | $26.39 | $73.88 | — | — | 64% |
| PhiladelphiaPennsylvania | $22.73 | $63.65 | $49.55 | $37.04 | 64% |
| PhoenixArizona | $16.10 | $45.07 | — | — | 64% |
| BostonMassachusetts | $35.74 | $89.36 | $51.98 | $42.26 | 60% |
| DetroitMichigan | $27.02 | $67.55 | $47.43 | $27.49 | 60% |
| SeattleWashington | $15.40 | $43.11 | — | — | 64% |
| Minneapolis–St. PaulMinnesota | $23.25 | $51.14 | $48.73 | $22.35 | 55% |
| DenverColorado | $19.93 | $49.82 | — | $28.12 | 60% |
| CharlotteNorth Carolina | $15.87 | $44.43 | $49.46 | $42.09 | 64% |
| BaltimoreMaryland | $22.41 | $62.75 | $51.90 | $44.70 | 64% |
| St. LouisMissouri | $16.84 | $47.15 | — | $24.23 | 64% |
| PortlandOregon | $16.72 | $46.80 | — | — | 64% |
Dollars per million Btu of heat delivered. Oil and propane are the EIA’s weekly home prices before tax, where it publishes them.
What the running cost leaves out
- Cooling. A heat pump is also an air conditioner. If yours is due for replacement, the extra cost of a heat pump over a new air conditioner is the number to weigh, not the whole price.
- The gas account's fixed charges. They stop only if nothing else in the house burns gas. They are part of the state averages above, so a home that keeps gas for hot water or cooking saves a little less than the table suggests.
- Rebates. Many utility and state rebates are for heat pumps. Each metro page lists the programs and their rules. Rebates and what they require.
- A hybrid system. A heat pump can share the ducts with a gas furnace and hand over to it on the coldest days. Where gas is cheaper to run, that keeps the bills low and still gives you efficient cooling and mild-weather heat.
- The house itself. Air sealing and insulation shrink the bill whatever heats the house, and they let a smaller system do the job. The planner puts those in order for your home.
- Prices change. These are today's prices. The tie price in the table tells you how far they would have to move to change the answer.
How it's worked out
- Energy prices: EIA state averages, retrieved October 12, 2026.
- Gas furnace: 95% efficient, the level of a new condensing furnace.
- Seasonal COP is the heat delivered over a whole heating season, including electric backup heat and defrost, for a heat pump sized for the house. We pick the planning value by how cold the winter is (heating degree days) and set it slightly below modelled results (Dunsky/CCI 2024), because measured field performance tends to come in lower. For your own house, the HSPF2 rating of the system you choose and your installer's Manual J load calculation are the better guide.
- The numbers are computed when the site is built, from the same data as the planner, so the two always agree.
Questions people ask
Is a heat pump cheaper to run than a gas furnace in the United States?
At today's prices an efficient heat pump costs less to run than a 95% gas furnace in 12 of the 26 metro areas we cover that have piped gas, and gas costs less in the other 14. The heat pump wins everywhere we cover in Texas, Georgia, Florida, Arizona, Washington, North Carolina and Oregon. Gas wins everywhere we cover in New York, California, Illinois, District of Columbia, Pennsylvania, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Colorado, Maryland and Missouri. The answer follows the local prices of gas and electricity far more than the brand of heat pump.
What gas price makes a heat pump cheaper to run?
Divide your electricity price per kWh by the heat pump's seasonal COP, then compare it with your gas price per unit of heat from a 95% furnace. In New York City, with electricity at 29.9¢ per kWh and a seasonal COP of 2.8, the two tie when gas costs $2.97 per therm; gas there costs $1.70. The table gives that tie price for every place we cover.
If gas is cheaper to run, is a heat pump ever worth it?
Often, for other reasons: it also cools, so it can replace an air conditioner that is due anyway; many rebates are for heat pumps; a hybrid setup keeps the furnace for the coldest days; and closing the gas account ends its fixed charges. Against oil, propane or electric baseboards the running cost usually favours the heat pump as well.
Why is the number on my bill different?
These are state-wide average residential prices from the EIA, so your utility's rates can be higher or lower, and they include the fixed monthly charges. Use your own price per kWh and per therm with the tie price in the table to check your case.
Sources and how this page is kept
What was checked when: Energy prices (retrieved from the EIA) .
Who wrote it. Edited by David Bussell. Every number on this page comes from the sources above or is worked out from them, with the date each was last checked. Found a mistake? Tell the editor and we'll fix it.
How it's paid for. On this site there are no referral fees, and we don’t pass your details to contractors. No maker pays to be in a guide, and no fee changes a pick. More about how the site runs.