Buying guide · Water heaters · 2026

Water heater buying guide for the United States

Which water heater costs least to run depends on what gas and electricity cost where you live and on how cold the water arrives. This guide works out a year of hot water from each type in 26 US metro areas.

The short version

  • With piped gas, the cheapest type to run is the gas tankless in 23 and the heat pump water heater in 3 of the 26 places we cover.
  • Without gas, a heat pump water heater costs less to run than an electric tank in 26 of 26 places.
  • Against an electric tank, a heat pump water heater saves $235 to $630 a year (least in Miami, most in San Francisco), after counting the house heat it uses in winter.
  • A gas tankless heater saves $80 to $185 a year against a gas tank. That rarely repays its higher price on energy alone; buy it for endless hot water or the space.
  • Most water heaters are replaced the day they fail. Choose the next one now and the better option is still on the table.

Replace now, or wait?

  • Replace now if the tank is leaking or rusting at the base, or the water runs rusty. A tank that fails floods the floor it sits on.
  • Plan the replacement once a tank is past about ten years old. A heat pump water heater or a tankless unit usually needs new wiring, venting or a drain, which is hard to arrange in an emergency.
  • Use less first. Low-flow showerheads and insulation on the first few feet of hot pipe cut the load on whatever heater you buy.

A year of hot water where you live

For 3 people using 59 gallons a day, heated from each place's average cold-water temperature (53°F in Minneapolis–St. Paul to 83°F in Miami). The cheapest type in each place is in green.

A year of hot water by type of water heater
Metro areaGas tankGas tanklessElectric tankHeat pump water heater
New York City $370$250$1,220$610
Los Angeles $410$270$1,190$600
Chicago $250$165$820$410
Dallas–Fort Worth $340$225$530$285
Greater Houston $320$210$500$245
Atlanta $380$250$580$320
Washington, DC $330$220$950$490
Miami $370$245$410$175
Philadelphia $310$205$860$440
Phoenix $275$185$440$200
All 26 metro areas
A year of hot water by type of water heater: every place we cover
Metro areaGas tankGas tanklessElectric tankHeat pump water heater
New York City $370$250$1,220$610
Los Angeles $410$270$1,190$600
Chicago $250$165$820$410
Dallas–Fort Worth $340$225$530$285
Greater Houston $320$210$500$245
Atlanta $380$250$580$320
Washington, DC $330$220$950$490
Miami $370$245$410$175
Philadelphia $310$205$860$440
Phoenix $275$185$440$200
Boston $550$370$1,280$680
Riverside $390$260$1,140$540
San Francisco $440$290$1,280$650
Detroit $245$160$990$480
Seattle $380$250$600$350
Minneapolis–St. Paul $260$170$790$400
Tampa $390$260$440$200
San Diego $400$265$1,170$570
Denver $250$165$720$370
Orlando $400$265$450$210
Charlotte $310$210$560$310
Baltimore $330$225$850$440
St. Louis $300$200$630$340
San Antonio $320$215$510$250
Austin $330$220$520$265
Portland $350$235$640$360

Efficiencies: gas tank 0.58, gas tankless 0.87, electric tank 0.92, heat pump 2.2 (a field figure from homes in the US Northeast; the label will show more). The heat pump column includes the extra space heating needed to replace the heat it takes from the house, priced at the heating most homes in each place have. A dash means no piped gas in our data.

The types, and who each one suits

Types of water heater
TypeGood forWatch for
Gas tankThe lowest price to buy where there is gas, and a like-for-like swap.Venting. A condensing furnace no longer warms a shared chimney, so the water heater's vent may need changing.
Gas tanklessEndless hot water and a free patch of floor.A saving of only $80 to $185 a year, a larger gas line and new venting, and less flow when the incoming water is coldest.
Electric tankThe simplest install: no vent, no gas.The highest running cost in most places with gas.
Heat pump water heaterHomes with an electric tank: it saves $235 to $630 a year.It cools and dries the room it sits in, needs air space and a drain, and makes some noise.

Sizing

  • NRCan's planning figure is about 20 gallons (75 liters) of hot water per person per day. Count the people who will live in the house, not the bathrooms.
  • Tanks: compare the first-hour rating on the label with your busiest hour (showers, a dishwasher and laundry together).
  • Tankless: the rated flow assumes a set temperature rise. The colder the incoming water, the less flow you get, so ask for the flow at your winter water temperature. Our average inlet figures run from 53°F to 83°F.
  • Heat pump water heaters: a larger tank lets the heat pump do more of the work before the backup element comes on.

Rebates

The federal tax credit for water heaters (25C) ended for equipment placed in service after December 31, 2025. The Home Electrification and Appliance Rebates pay for heat pump water heaters by income, but only where a state runs them. Which states are open. A Department of Energy rule sets new efficiency standards for most water heaters made from May 6, 2029; check where it stands before you plan around it.

Before you sign: the quote checklist

  1. The exact model number and its efficiency (UEF), and the tank size or tankless flow rate.
  2. Venting, the gas line or the electrical circuit, and the drain, priced in.
  3. For a heat pump water heater: the room's size, the clearances and where the condensate goes.
  4. For a tankless heater: the flow at your winter water temperature.
  5. Removal of the old heater, permits and the warranty terms.
  6. Proof the model is on the rebate program's list, and who applies.

Questions people ask

Is a tankless water heater worth it?

On energy alone, often not. For 3 people a gas tankless heater saves $80 to $185 a year (least in Detroit, most in Boston) against a standard gas tank, which over 12 years is worth $970 to $2,210 extra. The US Department of Energy found the saving is largest in homes that use little hot water and smallest in homes that use a lot. The other reasons to buy one are endless hot water and floor space.

How much does a heat pump water heater save?

Against an electric tank it saves $235 to $630 a year (least in Miami, most in San Francisco) for 3 people, after counting the heat it takes from the house in winter. Against a gas tank it costs less to run in 11 of the 26 places we cover with piped gas.

Which water heater is cheapest to run?

It depends on whether you have gas. In the 26 places we cover with piped gas, the cheapest to run is the gas tankless in 23 and the heat pump water heater in 3. Without gas, a heat pump water heater costs less to run than an electric tank in 26 of the 26 places we cover. The table has your place.

What size water heater do I need?

Start from how much hot water the household uses: NRCan's planning figure is about 20 gallons (75 liters) per person per day. For a tank, match the first-hour rating to your busiest hour. For a tankless heater, match the flow at your coldest incoming water temperature, which is what limits it in winter.

Does a heat pump water heater work in a cold basement?

Yes, with two cautions. It takes heat from the air around it, so in the heating season the house's heating has to replace that heat; our figures include it. And it needs enough air around it and a drain for the condensate, so check the maker's clearances before you buy.

Sources and how this page is kept

Hot water use is NRCan's about 20 gallons (75 liters) per person per day, heated to 131°F from each place's average cold-water temperature (annual mean air temperature plus 6°F, never below 41°F). The tankless figure uses rated efficiencies, which puts it at the generous end of the US Department of Energy's field range. We don't test water heaters.

What was checked when: Standards, criteria and guidance · Energy prices .

Who wrote it. Edited by David Bussell. Every number on this page comes from the sources above or is worked out from them, with the date each was last checked. Found a mistake? Tell the editor and we'll fix it.

How it's paid for. On this site there are no referral fees, and we don’t pass your details to contractors. No maker pays to be in a guide, and no fee changes a pick. More about how the site runs.