Buying guide · Furnaces · 2026

Furnace buying guide for the United States

What a new furnace saves depends on your winter, your gas price and the furnace you have now. This guide works the numbers out for 26 US metro areas and takes the decision in order.

The short version

  • New furnaces come in two kinds: standard (80% AFUE, the federal minimum) and condensing (95% and up). ENERGY STAR asks for 97% in northern states and 95% in southern ones.
  • Replacing a mid-efficiency (80%) furnace with a condensing (95%) one saves $5 to $295 a year (least in Miami, most in Boston) for our reference house.
  • The last step, 95% to 98%, saves only $0 to $50 a year. Pay for two stages or a modulating burner if you want steadier heat, not to cut the bill.
  • A cold-climate heat pump costs less to run than a 95% furnace in 12 of the 26 places we cover with piped gas. See yours.
  • The size comes from a heat-loss calculation (Manual J), not from the old furnace. Get it in writing.

Does the furnace need replacing?

Whether to repair or replace a furnace
What you haveWhat we'd do
A cracked heat exchanger, or carbon monoxide at the furnaceReplace it. Have a combustion safety test done on whatever stays in the house.
An old furnace with a pilot light or a metal chimney vent (around 60% to 80%)Plan the replacement now, before it fails in January. This is where the saving is largest: $20 to $920 a year against a 60% furnace.
A condensing furnace under about 15 years oldRepair it. A new furnace of the same efficiency saves nothing on fuel.
A furnace and an air conditioner that are both near the endPrice a heat pump before you replace either. It cools like an air conditioner and can take over most of the heating. Furnace or heat pump.

Before you size anything, measure the house

A furnace is sized to the heat the house loses on a cold day. Seal the leaks and top up the attic first and the house may need a smaller one.

What each efficiency level costs to run where you live

AFUE is the share of the gas that ends up as heat in the house over a season. NRCan: gas furnaces from around 1970 ran at about 60%, mid-1980s models at 78 to 84%, condensing furnaces at 90 to 98%. The table is a year of heat for a detached house of 1,600 sq ft built between 1966 and 1980, at each place's gas price.

A year of heat by furnace efficiency, and against a heat pump
Metro areaOld furnace (60%)Standard (80%)Condensing (95%)Top of the range (98%)Cold-climate heat pumpHeat pump is cheaper above COP
New York City $1,550$1,160$980$950$30 less$1,710seasonal COP 2.84.9
Los Angeles $480$360$300$295$10 less$480seasonal COP 2.84.4
Chicago $1,220$910$770$740$25 less$1,510seasonal COP 2.54.9
Dallas–Fort Worth $780$580$490$470$15 less$410seasonal COP 2.82.4
Greater Houston $440$330$280$270$10 less$235seasonal COP 2.82.4
Atlanta $930$700$590$570$20 less$480seasonal COP 2.82.3
Washington, DC $1,130$850$720$690$20 less$1,110seasonal COP 2.84.4
Miami $50$35$30$30$0 less$20seasonal COP 2.81.7
Philadelphia $1,220$920$770$750$25 less$1,150seasonal COP 2.84.2
Phoenix $290$220$185$180$5 less$160seasonal COP 2.82.4
All 26 metro areas
A year of heat by furnace efficiency, and against a heat pump: every place we cover
Metro areaOld furnace (60%)Standard (80%)Condensing (95%)Top of the range (98%)Cold-climate heat pumpHeat pump is cheaper above COP
New York City $1,550$1,160$980$950$30 less$1,710seasonal COP 2.84.9
Los Angeles $480$360$300$295$10 less$480seasonal COP 2.84.4
Chicago $1,220$910$770$740$25 less$1,510seasonal COP 2.54.9
Dallas–Fort Worth $780$580$490$470$15 less$410seasonal COP 2.82.4
Greater Houston $440$330$280$270$10 less$235seasonal COP 2.82.4
Atlanta $930$700$590$570$20 less$480seasonal COP 2.82.3
Washington, DC $1,130$850$720$690$20 less$1,110seasonal COP 2.84.4
Miami $50$35$30$30$0 less$20seasonal COP 2.81.7
Philadelphia $1,220$920$770$750$25 less$1,150seasonal COP 2.84.2
Phoenix $290$220$185$180$5 less$160seasonal COP 2.82.4
Boston $2,510$1,880$1,580$1,530$50 less$2,220seasonal COP 2.53.5
Riverside $550$410$350$340$10 less$550seasonal COP 2.84.4
San Francisco $980$740$620$600$20 less$980seasonal COP 2.84.4
Detroit $1,190$890$750$730$25 less$1,840seasonal COP 2.56.1
Seattle $1,390$1,040$880$850$25 less$760seasonal COP 2.82.4
Minneapolis–St. Paul $1,470$1,100$930$900$30 less$1,930seasonal COP 2.24.6
Tampa $200$150$125$120$5 less$75seasonal COP 2.81.7
San Diego $390$295$250$240$10 less$390seasonal COP 2.84.4
Denver $1,180$890$750$720$25 less$1,310seasonal COP 2.54.4
Orlando $240$180$150$150$5 less$95seasonal COP 2.81.7
Charlotte $900$680$570$550$15 less$540seasonal COP 2.82.7
Baltimore $1,310$980$830$800$25 less$1,130seasonal COP 2.83.8
St. Louis $1,190$890$750$730$25 less$840seasonal COP 2.83.1
San Antonio $500$380$320$310$10 less$270seasonal COP 2.82.4
Austin $600$450$380$370$10 less$320seasonal COP 2.82.4
Portland $1,230$930$780$760$25 less$770seasonal COP 2.82.8

Marginal energy prices (state averages); the gas account's fixed monthly charge is not included because it does not change with the furnace. Your house will use more or less than the reference house, but the differences between columns scale with it.

Three things stand out. The big saving is in retiring an old furnace: $20 to $920 a year (least in Miami, most in Boston). Choosing condensing over standard saves $5 to $295 a year, which is why it matters most in cold states and hardly at all in warm ones. And the top of the range saves little more: $0 to $50 a year, so over 15 years it is worth paying at most $730 extra for those three points, and usually far less.

The rule to watch: a federal standard would require 95% AFUE for furnaces made from December 18, 2028. On June 8, 2026 the US Supreme Court set aside the appeals-court decision that had upheld the rule and sent the case back; the Department of Energy has said it is considering a delay to 2030. Until a court or the Department acts, the December 18, 2028 date stands.

One stage, two stages or modulating, and the blower

  • Single stage. On at full power or off. The cheapest, and fine in a small or well-insulated house.
  • Two stage. Runs at a lower setting most of the time and at full power on the coldest days: longer, quieter cycles and more even rooms.
  • Modulating. Adjusts in small steps. NRCan notes staged and modulating furnaces fire at 60 to 100% of capacity for steadier cycles. The fuel saving over single stage is small; the comfort difference is what you pay for.
  • The blower motor. Ask for a brushless DC (ECM) motor. NRCan says it can cut a furnace's electricity use by more than 70% when the fan runs continuously, which matters if you filter or ventilate through the ducts.

Sizing

  • Ask for a room-by-room heat-loss calculation (Manual J) with the quote. The old furnace's size is not a guide: it is often larger than the house needs.
  • After insulation and air sealing a furnace can be oversized and run in short bursts. Size the new one to the house as it is now.
  • Have the installer confirm the ducts can carry the airflow, and measure it after the install.

What it costs to buy

Expect about $4,130 installed for a typical gas furnace, in 2022 dollars (US EIA, 2023). Prices have risen since, so treat it as a floor. The house and the contractor move the price more than the badge does.

  • Going from a 80% furnace to a condensing one means new plastic vent pipes through the wall and a drain for the condensate.
  • If the old furnace shared a chimney with a gas water heater, ask how the water heater will be vented once the furnace no longer warms the flue.
  • Two-stage and modulating models, a new thermostat and duct changes each add to the quote. Ask for them as separate lines.

Furnace, heat pump or both

A cold-climate heat pump costs less to run than a 95% gas furnace in 12 of the 26 places we cover with piped gas. The last column of the table above is the test for your place: the heat pump's heat is cheaper whenever its COP (units of heat per unit of electricity) is above that number. It runs from 1.7 in Miami to 6.1 in Detroit.

  • Where the number is below the seasonal COP in the heat pump column, the heat pump is cheaper over the whole winter. The heat pump guide covers the types and our picks.
  • Where it is above that, a hybrid can still pay: the heat pump heats in mild weather, when its COP is highest, and the furnace takes over in the cold. It works if the heat pump's certified COP at 8°C (47°F) is above the number for your place.
  • Where it is higher than any heat pump's COP, gas costs less to heat with at today's prices. A heat pump still replaces the air conditioner if you want one system for both.

Heat pump against gas furnace, place by place, with the gas price at which the two tie.

Rebates

The federal tax credit for furnaces (25C) ended for equipment placed in service after December 31, 2025. Check whether your gas utility pays for a high-efficiency furnace. The programs we track, by state.

Before you sign: the quote checklist

  1. The exact model number and its AFUE, and whether it is single stage, two stage or modulating.
  2. The heat-loss calculation (Manual J) the size is based on.
  3. A brushless DC (ECM) blower motor.
  4. How the furnace and the water heater will be vented, and where the condensate drains.
  5. Who registers the warranty, and by when.
  6. Permits, the gas connection and removal of the old furnace, priced in.
  7. A second quote for the same model, and a price for a heat pump or hybrid if the air conditioner is old.

Questions people ask

How much does a new furnace cost in the US?

Expect about $4,130 installed for a typical gas furnace, in 2022 dollars (US EIA, Updated Buildings Sector Appliance and Equipment Costs and Efficiencies (Guidehouse and Leidos, March 2023; 2022 dollars)). Prices have risen since then, so treat it as a floor. New venting, a chimney liner for the water heater, duct changes and a two-stage or modulating model add to it. Compare at least two quotes for the same model.

Is a 98% furnace worth it over a 95% one?

On fuel alone, rarely. In the 26 places we cover with piped gas, the step from 95% to 98% saves $0 to $50 a year (least in Miami, most in Boston) for a detached house of 1,600 sq ft built between 1966 and 1980. Over 15 years that is worth at most $730 extra, and far less in most places. Buy a two-stage or modulating furnace for steadier, quieter heat, not for the bill.

How much will a new furnace save?

It depends on what you have. Replacing a furnace from before about 1985 (around 60%) with a 95% one saves $20 to $920 a year (least in Miami, most in Boston) for our reference house. Replacing a mid-efficiency (80%) furnace saves $5 to $295 a year.

Should I replace my furnace with a heat pump?

On running cost it depends on local prices: a cold-climate heat pump costs less to run than a 95% gas furnace in 12 of the 26 places we cover with piped gas. If the air conditioner is also due, a heat pump that shares the ducts with a furnace (a hybrid) gets you both. Our heat pump guide and the place-by-place table take it from there.

What size furnace do I need?

The size comes from a room-by-room heat-loss calculation (Manual J), not from the old furnace's label or a rule per square foot. An oversized furnace costs more, runs in short bursts and heats less evenly. If you have insulated or air sealed since the old one went in, the house needs less than it did.

Are 80% furnaces being banned?

Not yet. The federal minimum is still 80% AFUE. A Department of Energy rule would require 95% for furnaces made from December 18, 2028. On June 8, 2026 the US Supreme Court set aside the appeals-court decision that had upheld the rule and sent the case back; the Department of Energy has said it is considering a delay to 2030. Until a court or the Department acts, the December 18, 2028 date stands.

How long does a furnace last?

Hydro One puts a typical furnace life at 15 to 20 years, and longer with regular service. Age alone is not a reason to replace one that is safe and heating the house.

Sources and how this page is kept

The reference house is a detached house of 1,600 sq ft built between 1966 and 1980; its heat demand comes from the same model as our planner, scaled to each place's heating degree days. Furnace efficiencies are NRCan's. We don't test furnaces, and we don't yet pick models: when we do, the picks will be drawn from certified lists and shown with their reasons, as the heat pump picks are.

What was checked when: Standards, criteria and guidance · Energy prices .

Who wrote it. Edited by David Bussell. Every number on this page comes from the sources above or is worked out from them, with the date each was last checked. Found a mistake? Tell the editor and we'll fix it.

How it's paid for. On this site there are no referral fees, and we don’t pass your details to contractors. No maker pays to be in a guide, and no fee changes a pick. More about how the site runs.