Buying guide · HRVs and ERVs · 2026
HRV and ERV buying guide for the United States
A heat recovery ventilator (HRV) or energy recovery ventilator (ERV) brings in outdoor air and uses the outgoing air to warm it. Whether that pays depends on your winter and your heating, so this guide works it out for 26 US metro areas.
The short version
- You buy an HRV or ERV for air quality and moisture control in a tight house. The recovered heat is what keeps the fresh air from costing much.
- For our reference house the recovered heat, less the fans' electricity, comes to between a net cost of $155 a year (San Diego) and a net saving of $45 (Boston). It comes out ahead in 6 of the 26 places we cover.
- HRV for a house that is damp in winter. ERV where winter air indoors gets very dry or summers are humid.
- Balancing at installation matters as much as the model. Ask for the measured airflows in writing.
Do you need one?
Every house needs outdoor air. A leaky house gets it through the cracks, at random and at full heating cost. A tight house needs a fan to supply it, and an HRV or ERV is the fan that gives most of the heat back.
- Yes, if windows drip in winter, the air is stale, or you are about to air seal and insulate. NRCan's rule: where there is already excessive condensation and the moisture sources can't be cut, airtightening has to come with mechanical ventilation.
- Maybe not, if the house is leaky and dry in winter. Seal it first, then ventilate on purpose.
- Check first that the bathroom and kitchen fans work and vent outdoors. They are the cheapest fix for moisture at the source.
Measure before you buy
- A blower door test measures how tight the house is, which decides how much ventilation it needs.
- An air quality monitor with a carbon dioxide reading shows whether bedrooms get enough fresh air overnight.
- A combustion safety test confirms fans are not pulling exhaust back down a chimney.
What the recovered heat is worth where you live
A year of continuous ventilation at 78 cfm, ASHRAE 62.2's rate for a 1,600 sq ft, 3-bedroom house, for a detached house of 1,600 sq ft built between 1966 and 1980. Heat is priced at the heating most homes in each place have, named under the first figure.
| Metro area | Heat the ventilation air carries out | Recovered at 65% | The fans' electricity | Net, a year |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| New York City | $210Gas furnace, mid-efficiency | $135 | $170 | −$35 |
| Los Angeles | $65Gas furnace, mid-efficiency | $40 | $190 | −$150 |
| Chicago | $165Gas furnace, mid-efficiency | $105 | $110 | $0 |
| Dallas–Fort Worth | $105Gas furnace, mid-efficiency | $70 | $90 | −$20 |
| Greater Houston | $60Gas furnace, mid-efficiency | $40 | $90 | −$50 |
| Atlanta | $125Gas furnace, mid-efficiency | $80 | $95 | −$10 |
| Washington, DC | $155Gas furnace, mid-efficiency | $100 | $145 | −$45 |
| Miami | $5Gas furnace, mid-efficiency | $5 | $85 | −$80 |
| Philadelphia | $165Gas furnace, mid-efficiency | $110 | $125 | −$15 |
| Phoenix | $40Gas furnace, mid-efficiency | $25 | $90 | −$60 |
All 26 metro areas
| Metro area | Heat the ventilation air carries out | Recovered at 65% | The fans' electricity | Net, a year |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| New York City | $210Gas furnace, mid-efficiency | $135 | $170 | −$35 |
| Los Angeles | $65Gas furnace, mid-efficiency | $40 | $190 | −$150 |
| Chicago | $165Gas furnace, mid-efficiency | $105 | $110 | $0 |
| Dallas–Fort Worth | $105Gas furnace, mid-efficiency | $70 | $90 | −$20 |
| Greater Houston | $60Gas furnace, mid-efficiency | $40 | $90 | −$50 |
| Atlanta | $125Gas furnace, mid-efficiency | $80 | $95 | −$10 |
| Washington, DC | $155Gas furnace, mid-efficiency | $100 | $145 | −$45 |
| Miami | $5Gas furnace, mid-efficiency | $5 | $85 | −$80 |
| Philadelphia | $165Gas furnace, mid-efficiency | $110 | $125 | −$15 |
| Phoenix | $40Gas furnace, mid-efficiency | $25 | $90 | −$60 |
| Boston | $340Gas furnace, mid-efficiency | $220 | $175 | $45 |
| Riverside | $75Gas furnace, mid-efficiency | $50 | $190 | −$145 |
| San Francisco | $135Gas furnace, mid-efficiency | $85 | $190 | −$105 |
| Detroit | $160Gas furnace, mid-efficiency | $105 | $130 | −$25 |
| Seattle | $190Gas furnace, mid-efficiency | $120 | $85 | $40 |
| Minneapolis–St. Paul | $200Gas furnace, mid-efficiency | $130 | $100 | $30 |
| Tampa | $25Gas furnace, mid-efficiency | $20 | $85 | −$70 |
| San Diego | $55Gas furnace, mid-efficiency | $35 | $190 | −$155 |
| Denver | $160Gas furnace, mid-efficiency | $105 | $95 | $5 |
| Orlando | $35Gas furnace, mid-efficiency | $20 | $85 | −$65 |
| Charlotte | $120Gas furnace, mid-efficiency | $80 | $85 | −$5 |
| Baltimore | $175Gas furnace, mid-efficiency | $115 | $120 | −$5 |
| St. Louis | $160Gas furnace, mid-efficiency | $105 | $90 | $15 |
| San Antonio | $70Gas furnace, mid-efficiency | $45 | $90 | −$45 |
| Austin | $80Gas furnace, mid-efficiency | $55 | $90 | −$40 |
| Portland | $165Gas furnace, mid-efficiency | $110 | $90 | $20 |
Recovery at 65%, the minimum ENERGY STAR sets in Canada at 0°C; better units recover more. Fan power at 1.2 cfm per watt, the same specification's minimum, which gives 65 watts running all year. An exhaust fan moving the same air would also use electricity, so the true extra cost is a little lower. An ERV also cuts the cooling and drying load in a humid summer, which is not counted here.
Over 15 years the net figure is what the recovery is worth paying for, compared with exhaust fans alone: up to $710 (Boston), and nothing in places where it is negative. Where it is small or negative, the case for an HRV or ERV rests on comfort and air quality, not on the bill.
HRV or ERV
| HRV | ERV | |
|---|---|---|
| What it moves | Heat only. | Heat and some moisture. |
| In winter | Sends more of the indoor moisture outdoors, so it dries the house. | Keeps some moisture in, so the air is less dry. |
| In a humid summer | Brings outdoor humidity in. | Keeps more of it out, which helps the air conditioner. |
| Suits | Houses that are damp in winter. | Houses that get very dry in winter, very dry climates, and places with humid summers and air conditioning. |
NRCan recommends an ERV where cooling loads are high, where indoor moisture is very low, or in very dry climates such as northern Canada. For an ERV in a cold climate, check it was tested at low temperature.
The ratings that matter
- Sensible recovery efficiency (SRE). The share of heat recovered after fan energy, leakage and frost control. Compare it at 0°C and at −25°C (32°F and −13°F). ENERGY STAR in Canada requires at least 65% and 60%.
- Fan efficacy. Airflow for each watt of fan power. The same specification requires at least 1.2 cfm per watt for most units. The fans run all year, so this number is on your bill every month.
- Airflow. The unit has to deliver the house's ventilation rate at low speed with capacity to spare for a boost.
- Certification. Look for figures certified by the Home Ventilating Institute.
Installation decides whether it works
- Its own ducts, or the furnace's. NRCan notes an HRV with its own ducts can be the most efficient setup, especially in a house without ductwork. Tied into furnace ducts, it needs the furnace fan to run, so an efficient (ECM) blower motor matters.
- Balancing. The air in has to match the air out. Too much in pushes moist air into the walls; too much out can pull exhaust down a chimney. Ask for the measured airflows on paper.
- Where the air goes. Fresh air to bedrooms and living rooms, stale air from bathrooms and the kitchen area.
Upkeep
- Clean or replace the filters every one to three months.
- Clean the core and check the condensate drain about every six months.
- Keep the outdoor hoods clear of snow, leaves and lint.
- Most units defrost automatically in the cold. A core that keeps freezing points to dirty filters, a defrost fault or an unbalanced system.
Before you sign: the quote checklist
- The model, its SRE at 0°C and −25°C, and its fan efficacy, from the certified listing.
- The ventilation rate the house needs and how it was worked out.
- Where each supply and exhaust point goes, and whether it has its own ducts.
- Balancing after installation, with the measured airflows left with you.
- The controls: continuous low speed, with a boost switch in the bathrooms.
- What maintenance is yours, and where the filters are.
More buying guides
Questions people ask
Does an HRV pay for itself?
On energy alone it depends on what you heat with. For a detached house of 1,600 sq ft built between 1966 and 1980 ventilated at 78 cfm, the heat an HRV recovers, less the electricity its fans use, comes to between a net cost of $155 a year (San Diego) and a net saving of $45 (Boston). It comes out ahead in 6 of the 26 places we cover. The reason to buy one is fresh air and moisture control in a tight house; the recovered heat is what makes that affordable.
HRV or ERV: which do I need?
An HRV moves heat only and sends more of the winter moisture outdoors, which suits a house that is damp in winter. An ERV also moves moisture: NRCan recommends one where cooling loads are high, where indoor air gets very dry in winter, or in very dry climates, and Health Canada notes it helps keep summer humidity out.
Do I need an HRV at all?
If the house is tight, yes: it needs a steady supply of outdoor air that the leaks no longer provide. NRCan's rule is that if a house already shows excessive condensation and the moisture sources can't be reduced, any work that makes it more airtight has to include mechanical ventilation. A blower door test tells you how tight the house is.
What ratings should I compare?
Sensible recovery efficiency (SRE) at 0°C and at −25°C, and fan efficacy (airflow per watt). ENERGY STAR in Canada requires at least 65% at 0°C and 60% at −25°C; NRCan says a typical HRV recovers 70% to 80%. The Home Ventilating Institute lists certified figures for each model.
How much maintenance does an HRV need?
Clean or replace the filters every one to three months, clean the core and check the drain about twice a year, and keep the outdoor hoods clear of snow and leaves. A unit with clogged filters moves little air and can freeze.
Sources and how this page is kept
Heat carried out by ventilation air = airflow × 1.21 kJ per cubic meter per degree × each place's heating degree days. We count the heating season only and assume the unit runs all year at one speed. We don't test ventilators, and we hold no current installed-price source, so the guide gives what the recovery is worth instead of a price.
What was checked when: Standards, criteria and guidance · Energy prices .
Who wrote it. Edited by David Bussell. Every number on this page comes from the sources above or is worked out from them, with the date each was last checked. Found a mistake? Tell the editor and we'll fix it.
How it's paid for. On this site there are no referral fees, and we don’t pass your details to contractors. No maker pays to be in a guide, and no fee changes a pick. More about how the site runs.