Buying guide · Boilers · 2026

Boiler buying guide for the United States

A boiler heats water for radiators or a heated floor. What a new one saves depends on your winter and your gas price, and on one setting most quotes never mention: the temperature of the water. This guide works the numbers out for 26 US metro areas with piped gas.

The short version

  • Replacing an old boiler (around 60%) with a condensing one saves $15 to $820 a year (least in Miami, most in Boston) for our reference house.
  • A condensing boiler only earns its rating when the return water is at about 115 to 120°F or cooler. Otherwise it runs at about 89%.
  • Getting the water temperature right is worth a further $0 to $105 a year. Ask for an outdoor reset control and for the boiler to be set up to use it.
  • ENERGY STAR asks for 90% AFUE for gas boilers and 87% for oil.
  • A ductless heat pump beside the boiler adds cooling and takes over much of the heating.

Does the boiler need replacing?

  • Replace it if it leaks, the heat exchanger is cracked, or a combustion safety test finds it spilling exhaust.
  • Plan the replacement of an old standard-efficiency boiler (around 60%): that is where the saving is largest, $15 to $820 a year.
  • Keep and tune a newer boiler that is safe. Controls, balancing the radiators and insulating the pipes cost far less than a new boiler.

Before you size anything, measure the house

Insulation and air sealing do two things for a boiler: the house needs a smaller one, and the radiators can heat it with cooler water, which is what lets a condensing boiler or a heat pump work well.

What each kind of boiler costs to run where you live

A year of heat for a detached house of 1,600 sq ft built between 1966 and 1980, at each place's gas price.

A year of heat by boiler efficiency
Metro areaOld boiler (60%)Non-condensing (82%)Condensing, hot return water (89%)Condensing, cool return water (95%)
New York City $1,550$1,130$1,040$980$65 less
Los Angeles $480$350$320$300$20 less
Chicago $1,220$890$820$770$50 less
Dallas–Fort Worth $780$570$520$490$35 less
Greater Houston $440$320$300$280$20 less
Atlanta $930$680$630$590$40 less
Washington, DC $1,130$830$760$720$50 less
Miami $50$35$30$30$0 less
Philadelphia $1,220$890$820$770$50 less
Phoenix $290$215$195$185$10 less
All 26 metro areas
A year of heat by boiler efficiency: every place we cover
Metro areaOld boiler (60%)Non-condensing (82%)Condensing, hot return water (89%)Condensing, cool return water (95%)
New York City $1,550$1,130$1,040$980$65 less
Los Angeles $480$350$320$300$20 less
Chicago $1,220$890$820$770$50 less
Dallas–Fort Worth $780$570$520$490$35 less
Greater Houston $440$320$300$280$20 less
Atlanta $930$680$630$590$40 less
Washington, DC $1,130$830$760$720$50 less
Miami $50$35$30$30$0 less
Philadelphia $1,220$890$820$770$50 less
Phoenix $290$215$195$185$10 less
Boston $2,510$1,830$1,690$1,580$105 less
Riverside $550$400$370$350$25 less
San Francisco $980$720$660$620$40 less
Detroit $1,190$870$800$750$50 less
Seattle $1,390$1,020$940$880$60 less
Minneapolis–St. Paul $1,470$1,070$990$930$60 less
Tampa $200$145$135$125$10 less
San Diego $390$285$265$250$15 less
Denver $1,180$870$800$750$50 less
Orlando $240$175$165$150$10 less
Charlotte $900$660$610$570$40 less
Baltimore $1,310$960$880$830$55 less
St. Louis $1,190$870$800$750$50 less
San Antonio $500$370$340$320$20 less
Austin $600$440$400$380$25 less
Portland $1,230$900$830$780$55 less

Efficiencies are NRCan's seasonal figures: about 82% for a non-condensing boiler and about 89% for a condensing boiler as most are run, against a rating of 95% or more. The gas account's fixed charge is not included. Heating with oil: replacing an old oil boiler with a new one (86%) saves $730 to $1,750 a year in the 7 places where we hold a home heating oil price.

The water temperature decides what you get

A condensing boiler gets its extra efficiency by cooling its exhaust until the water vapor in it condenses. That only happens when the water returning from the radiators is cool enough: about 115 to 120°F or less. On a system that runs hotter than that all winter, it never condenses.

  • Outdoor reset. A control that lowers the water temperature as the weather warms. Ask for one, and for the installer to set its curve. It is what puts the boiler in condensing range for most of the winter.
  • Radiators. The more radiator surface a room has for the heat it loses, the cooler the water can be. Insulating the house has the same effect.
  • The check. Ask the installer what supply and return temperatures the system will run at on a mild day and on the coldest day, and write them on the quote.

Over 15 years the difference between a condensing boiler run hot and one run cool is worth up to $1,600 for our reference house. It costs a control and the time to set it up.

Sizing

  • Ask for a room-by-room heat-loss calculation (Manual J). The old boiler's size is not a guide.
  • A modulating boiler turns its flame down in mild weather. Ask for the lowest output it can hold: one that cannot turn down far enough will switch on and off.
  • Steam systems are different: the boiler is matched to the radiators, and condensing boilers do not apply.

Heat pump options for a house with radiators

  • A ductless heat pump beside the boiler. One or two wall heads heat and cool the main rooms; the boiler covers the rest of the house and the coldest days. The heat pump guide has the types, our picks and the rebates.
  • An air-to-water heat pump. It feeds the radiators or a heated floor, with cooler water than a boiler makes. It suits heated floors and well-insulated houses with generous radiators.
  • Either way, the work that lets a condensing boiler run cool (insulation, air sealing, reset control) is the same work that makes a house ready for a heat pump.

What a heat pump's heat costs against gas, place by place.

Hot water from the boiler

  • An indirect tank is a storage tank heated by the boiler. It has no burner or vent of its own.
  • A combination ("combi") boiler heats tap water on demand and saves the space of a tank. Its hot water flow is limited, so check it against two showers running at once.
  • A separate water heater is still an option. The water heater guide has a year of hot water for each type at your prices.

Before you sign: the quote checklist

  1. The exact model, its AFUE and its lowest and highest output.
  2. The heat-loss calculation (Manual J) the size is based on.
  3. An outdoor reset control, and the supply and return temperatures it will be set to.
  4. Venting, the condensate drain and a neutralizer if the local code asks for one.
  5. How hot water will be made: indirect tank, combi or a separate heater.
  6. Flushing the old system and fitting a filter to protect the new heat exchanger.
  7. Who registers the warranty, and what yearly service it requires.

Questions people ask

How much does a new boiler save?

Against an old standard-efficiency boiler (around 60%), a condensing boiler saves $15 to $820 a year (least in Miami, most in Boston) for a detached house of 1,600 sq ft built between 1966 and 1980. Against a newer non-condensing boiler (82%) it saves $5 to $145 a year.

Is a condensing boiler worth it?

Only if it is set up to condense. A condensing boiler reaches its rating when the water comes back from the radiators at about 115 to 120°F or cooler; with hotter return water it performs like a non-condensing one. An outdoor reset control, which lowers the water temperature in mild weather, is what gets it there. Set up well, it saves a further $0 to $105 a year over the same boiler run hot.

What size boiler do I need?

The size comes from a room-by-room heat-loss calculation (Manual J), not from the old boiler's label or the length of radiator in the house. Old boilers are often far larger than the house needs, and a house that has been insulated since needs less again.

Can I use a heat pump with radiators?

Yes, two ways. A ductless heat pump heats and cools the main rooms while the boiler covers the rest and the coldest days. An air-to-water heat pump feeds the radiators directly, but it makes cooler water than a boiler, so the radiators must be large enough to heat the rooms with it.

How much does a new boiler cost?

The US EIA put a typical gas boiler at about $5,940 installed in 2022 dollars. Prices have risen since, so treat it as a floor. New venting, a chimney liner, zone valves and an indirect water heater each add to the quote.

Sources and how this page is kept

The reference house is a detached house of 1,600 sq ft built between 1966 and 1980; its heat demand comes from the same model as our planner, scaled to each place's heating degree days. The old-boiler figure is NRCan's for old standard-efficiency gas equipment. We don't test boilers, and we don't yet pick models.

What was checked when: Standards, criteria and guidance · Energy prices .

Who wrote it. Edited by David Bussell. Every number on this page comes from the sources above or is worked out from them, with the date each was last checked. Found a mistake? Tell the editor and we'll fix it.

How it's paid for. On this site there are no referral fees, and we don’t pass your details to contractors. No maker pays to be in a guide, and no fee changes a pick. More about how the site runs.