Method · checked November 12, 2026
How we pick heat pumps
Every pick is computed from ENERGY STAR's certified ratings and the warranty terms we have read, using the same gates and the same weights for every brand. An editor can override a computed pick, and the reason is then printed on the page. No brand pays to be considered, and no pick is for sale.
Three picks, three questions
| Pick | The question it answers | How it's decided |
|---|---|---|
| Best performance | What would you buy if comfort and running cost mattered most? | The top score for the zone among every certified system that passed the gates, in the size range for the situation. |
| Best do-it-yourself | What can a handy owner install safely, legally and with the warranty intact? | The best-scoring system sold for owner installation, with pre-charged quick-connect lines and a warranty that covers an owner install. The new circuit is still an electrician’s job. In very cold zones it shows as a supplement when it keeps less heat than the zone needs. |
| Best value | What gives the most back for the money here? | The top score among brands we place in the budget or mid price tier. It must pass every gate the performance pick passes. |
We pick separately for three situations, because they need different equipment: a house with ducts (a central system of 2 to 4 tons), a house without ducts (a wall-mounted head of 1 to 2 tons for a floor or an open main level) and one room (half a ton to 1 ton).
The gates
A system must pass all of these before it is scored. They are pass or fail, never a few points off.
- Sold in the country, with warranty terms we have read for that country. Brands whose terms we haven't confirmed yet aren't eligible.
- A current refrigerant (R-454B or R-32).
- A variable-speed compressor.
- In cold zones, ENERGY STAR's cold-climate designation; in Canada, also NRCan's rebate thresholds (COP of at least 1.8 at −15°C and at least 70% of rated output there).
- In very cold zones, at least 80% of rated heat output kept at −15°C (5°F); in the North, 85%.
- Like for like: 2 to 4 tons for houses with ducts, 1 to 2 tons for a ductless head, 0.5 to 1 ton for one room.
Not eligible yet, because we haven't read their warranty terms for the US: AUX, Cooper & Hunter, DuraSTAR, Hitachi, Innova (formerly Ephoca), Panasonic, TCL. They will be scored as soon as we have.
How each climate weighs the numbers
Each number is scaled from 0 to 1 across the systems that passed the gates, then weighted. Cold zones lean on efficiency and output at 5°F; hot zones on cooling efficiency, and on EER2 where afternoons are hottest. Warranty is the maker's registered term in the US, our stand-in for reliability until we have enough installer and owner feedback.
| Climate | COP at 5°F | Heat kept at 5°F | HSPF2 | SEER2 | EER2 | Warranty |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Very cold wintersVery cold | 30% | 35% | 15% | 5% | — | 15% |
| Cold wintersCold and humid, Cold and dry | 30% | 25% | 20% | 10% | — | 15% |
| Cold winters and hot summersMixed-humid | 15% | 10% | 25% | 20% | 15% | 15% |
| Mild winters and hot summersWarm mixed-humid | 10% | 10% | 20% | 25% | 20% | 15% |
| Hot, humid summersHot and humid | — | — | 15% | 35% | 30% | 20% |
| Very hot, dry summersHot and dry | — | — | 10% | 30% | 40% | 20% |
| Mild wintersMild coastal, Marine | 10% | 10% | 35% | 25% | — | 20% |
What we don't do, yet
- We don't test heat pumps in a lab. The numbers are ENERGY STAR's certified ratings for each exact outdoor and indoor pairing.
- We don't rate reliability beyond the warranty. Brand-level surveys exist, but we can't publish them; installer and owner feedback will come in as we broker quotes.
- We don't price individual models. Installed prices depend on the house and the contractor far more than on the badge, so cards show the published range for the type of system.
- Every rating stops at 5°F. In colder places, ask the installer for the maker's output at your design temperature.
What changes a pick
- A new ENERGY STAR list (we refresh it monthly) with a better-scoring system, or a pick dropped from it.
- A change to a maker's warranty or to where it sells.
- A rebate rule that a pick stops meeting.
- An editor's override, always with the reason printed beside the pick.
Changes are dated on this page and on each zone page.